Title:
Option to force default icon when viewing "my style"
Area:
styles, usability, reading
Summary:
I would like to be able to choose only to see other users' default icons when I load a page in my style.
Description:
I find the many different icons some users post and comment with very confusing and distracting. I keep having to double check who is who, and sometimes think one user is another if they use a similar icon.
I know I have the option to not show any icons and differentiate users by assigning them a color, but I prefer a calm black on white lay-out, and I don't think I would be able to distinguish the colors well enough to tell people apart anyway.
For me, consistent icons are the easiest way to recognize users, and it would make dreamwidth more accessible if there was an option to always show the default icon, or alternatively, to assign an icon to a user the way we're able to assign a color to a user now.
The good thing about forcing default icons is that users would have a say about how they represent themselves, and that it would probably be relatively simple to code. The minor draw back is that a few users might change their default icon so often that they remain difficult for very visually oriented users to identify.
Assigning an icon to a user in my style would be my preferred solution, all things being equal. I'd like to pick one of their personal icons that I feel that I can reliably recognize, the way that we now have the option to pick a color on the manage circle page. I would be happy to use one of my own icon slots for every icon I assigned, that way it wouldn't be a problem if they deleted their icons.
I'd be very happy with either solution.
Poll #1675 Option to force default icon when viewing "my style"
Open to: Registered Users, detailed results viewable to: All, participants: 37
This suggestion:
View AnswersShould be implemented as-is.
6 (16.2%)
Should be implemented with changes. (please comment)
13 (35.1%)
Shouldn't be implemented.
12 (32.4%)
(I have no opinion)
5 (13.5%)
(Other: please comment)
1 (2.7%)