Notification when tags change on an entry

[cesy]

Title:
Notification when tags change on an entry

Area:
notifications

Summary:
Optional notification when tags on a post change, particularly when an admin changes the tags on your community post.

Description:
I just noticed that a load of suggestions had tags added to show if they've been migrated. And I realised that nothing told me when an admin added a tag to my own posts. I'd quite like to know when that kind of thing happens, just as when the mod cutting feature is added, I'd like to know if a mod adds a cut tag to my post, or changes its security. Can an optional notification be triggered when tags change on a post? It's also something I'd like to be able to track on other posts, just like tracking comments.

Poll #949 Notification when tags change on an entry

Open to: Registered Users, detailed results viewable to: All, participants: 42

View Respondents

This suggestion:

View Answers

Should be implemented as-is.
30 (71.4%)

Should be implemented with changes.
1 (2.4%)

Shouldn't be implemented.
2 (4.8%)

(I have no opinion)
9 (21.4%)

(Other: please comment)
0 (0.0%)

Comments

[sofiaviolet]

I'd love this for many reasons.

One of which is that I track comments on dw_suggestions posts which interest me (which is most of them), and I want to know when they're tagged as migrated or rejected, so I can untrack them.

[turlough]

I like this suggestion A LOT!!

[triadruid]

I'll go a step further, even; whenever someone edits/deletes/cuts a post of yours, you should get a notification. Tracking could, perhaps, be turned off, but otherwise it's just asking for drama and trouble.

[galateus]

Yeah. A way to be notified of *any* changes to a post would be good--changes to the content(including added cuts), entry title, security settings(comments disabled, community-locked, etc.) or the tags.

[ciaan]

Oh, yes, being notified when mods do something to your comm posts would be great.

Being able to track tagging on other people's entries I don't really care about, but I'm not against it.

[azurelunatic]

Yes. I'd like to know what they were changed from, and what they were changed to, in the email. Not just a "btw they changed" tag.

[elizabeth_rice]

I have a community (closed membership) where only I have posting access. How would this affect me? Would I get a notification if I edited my own entries/tags in my community?

[cesy]

I was assuming it would only be when other people edited them on your entries, but I suppose that could be an option as well.

[elizabeth_rice]

I suppose that could be an option as well.
What could be an option?

[cesy]

To be notified when you edited tags on your own entries as well as being notified when other people edited tags on your entries.

[elizabeth_rice]

Ok, if you meant:
On the notifications settings page, there is a section called 'People and Communities'. If they add it as an option there: "notify me if a maintainer edits my entry/tag", I wouldn't mind it then, because I can de-select it.

[cesy]

That was what I was thinking of. It would probably be on as default for new users, because it's disconcerting to have stuff changed without you knowing, but off as default for existing users because that's what people are used to, and anyone who wants to can tick the box when it's announced in News.

[triadruid]

Ugh. I generally hate things that depend on when you started your account at sites where having more than one account is feasible, because it can really throw you off to have worked with X method for 7 years, only to find out with your new account/RP character/whatever that 3 years ago, the default was changed to Y method and everybody's looking at you like you grew a third head.

[cesy]

Hmm, that makes sense. How should it be introduced, then? A new feature for everyone should ideally be opt-in rather than opt-out, but this one makes so much more sense as opt-out.

[triadruid]

I actually think most things should be opt-out unless they're going to have privacy/intellectual property implications. New features should not be feared, they should be vetted, tested, betaed, and modified as needed. :)