Title:
Direct Message re: This Entry
Area:
Messages, Entries, Comments
Summary:
Allow people to send a direct message re: an entry instead of commenting on it
Description:
"As it currently stands, comment screening is used for two very different purposes. It's used to allow the journal owner to check over comments before they are visible, and it's used to make private comments that are never intended to be seen by anyone other than the journal owner. I propose that this functionality be split in two." -rho
The reason that a number of commenters favor allowing commenters to screen entries and/or to split up the comment function into entry discussion and sending a private message is that sending a direct message requires a commenter to (a) go to a separate page and (b) invoke the entry to which they are responding.
I propose that, instead, we permit someone to respond to an entry in the form of a comment, but then, with a tickybox, "send comment as direct message instead", send the OP a direct message whose subject line is the entry being commented upon, in the format
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
RE: example.dreamwidth.org/12345.html where you wrote:
[first 250 characters of entry]
example commenter responded:
[a message they want to send the OP but not anyone else]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This will allow people to have the direct communication they want in a format where the OP can't inadvertently reveal their direct communication to the other people reading the entry, and it won't require them to go to any other pages or summarize the entry, as this will be done automatically.
The drawback, from the journal owner's point of view, is that discussion will be disaggregated. I am not particularly concerned about this, as people always had the option of sending the OP a direct message or an e-mail or making an entry in their own journal in response.
The big drawback from the direct message sender's point of view is that the OP may allow people to make comments who are not allowed to send direct message's.
In this case, I suggest we degrade gracefully and say, "You do not have permission to post the message below"
[text box with the commenter's message, so that they can copy it or send an e-mail or whatever they need]
[button: comment on the entry] [button: cancel sending message] [link: return to entry]
Open to: Registered Users, detailed results viewable to: All, participants: 67
This suggestion:
View AnswersShould be implemented as-is.
29 (43.3%)
Should be implemented with changes. (please comment)
8 (11.9%)
Shouldn't be implemented.
6 (9.0%)
(I have no opinion)
21 (31.3%)
(Other: please comment)
3 (4.5%)